Recreating Perfection: Dal Makhani (Creamy Black Lentils)

You know how there is always this ONE recipe that no matter how hard you try to replicate, you never seem to be able to hit it just right? Somehow, the taste of when you first devoured the dish still lingers on your palate, and even after a dozen of your experimented versions later, you still know that it’s not quite as close to the original. Well for me, I have one too many of those!
There’s the PERFECT Mee Goreng served by the street hawker down the lane from my Grandma’s house in Malaysia, the spicy Chole garnished with fresh chopped onions and served with giant-sized crisp Bhaturas in Delhi and the most amazingly luscious melt-in-your-mouth Tiramisu served at a corner cafe by the Colosseum in Rome, to name just a few! But of all of them, the ONE recipe that has me searching non-stop for a close flavour duplicate would definitely have to be of Dal Makhani from a little nondescript restaurant in Kuwait.
Growing up, I remember eating off the restaurant’s classic menu once too often. They were especially known for their fantastic and lip-smacking combination of Chicken Tikka, Dal Makhani and Puris. But for me, a die-hard Chicken Tikka devotee, it was always their Dal Makhani that did the deed. It’s thick, warm and creamy texture was everything I craved for anytime of the year.
Ever since I moved away from home, I have always been on a search for a Dal Makhani that would come close to my childhood indulgence. But alas, none came even near an inch to tasting anything like it. I went high and low, to some of the most fabulous Indian restaurants as well as the local take-out favourites, but none of them could win me over. I had almost given up ordering the dreaded dish until one day my Mom decided to come to my rescue. She played and she toiled a few recipes, added this and subtracted that from the ingredients, and simplified the method to suit her needs, and Voila! What can I say? Now whenever I crave some lip-smacking comfort food, all I do is enter my kitchen. It’s a perfect go-to recipe this time of year, and I need I add, an absolute hit at my Diwali bash last weekend!
This is my contribution to Meeta’s Monthly Mingle - Traditional Feasts. A perfect pick when you want to give you menu that special facelift!
DAL MAKHANI
CREAMY BLACK LENTILS
Prep time: 10 min | Cooking time: 30 min | Serves: 4
Special Cooking Equipment: Pressure Cooker1/2 cup whole black lentils and a handful of dried red kidney beans, soaked overnight
1 large onion, finely chopped
1 medium-sized tomato, finely chopped
2-3 cloves of garlic
1 tbsp ginger-garlic paste
1 tbsp tomato paste
2 tbsp milk
1/2 tsp red chili powder
1 tbsp butter
2 tbsp cooking oil
fresh coriander leaves, chopped for garnish
water, as needed
salt, to tasteHEAT oil in a pressure cooker and saute onions till lightly browned. Stir in salt, chilli powder, ginger-garlic paste, and tomato paste and fry for a few seconds.
ADD in the chopped tomatoes and cook for a few minutes to combine well. Add lentils and beans, and enough water to cover them. Pressure cook for 15-20 minutes till lentils are soft and done. Stir in milk and let it come to a boil.
IN a separate pan, make a tempering by heating butter and whole garlic cloves slit in the middle. Stir the tempering into the lentils and garnish with fresh coriander leaves.
SERVE warm with soft, fluffy Naans.

November 14th, 2007 15:02
Wow this sounds fabulous, I really have to get a pressure cooker! Otherwise this would take hours..
November 14th, 2007 15:36
Yup! This does sound and look perfect Meena:) Hope you had a great Diwali, and belated wishes!!
-Mansi
November 14th, 2007 15:40
This is awesome and very tasty and yummy …..
November 14th, 2007 18:31
It drives me crazy when there’s a dish like that, my friends mom cooks food that I can never replicate or get anywhere else…It’s horrible! I crave it like crazy! The dal looks great
November 14th, 2007 19:41
this does look perfect. thanks for the recipe. i hate those things with an oil slick on the top.
November 14th, 2007 20:06
I have never used black lentils for this dish! Time to try!
luks yum! I luv dal makhani
November 14th, 2007 20:41
God bless you, Meenakshi. I kept looking for dal makhani recipes and wasn’t convinced about them. Now that my favorite food writer has given her own, simple-sounding recipe, I’m going to try this tomorrow!!
November 14th, 2007 23:14
Dal Makhani is an all time favourtie dal and urs looks perfect
November 14th, 2007 23:20
my all time….all time fav thing on earth!!!
November 15th, 2007 00:42
This looks delightful. And it seems so light and flavorful. Many thanks!
November 15th, 2007 08:57
i always have this in restaurent but i never tryed at home and your recipe and pic both looks sooo yummyyyyyy i will defenetly try this recipe at home
November 15th, 2007 09:32
A reason to go out and buy a pressure cooker! Thanks Meena - it looks amazing. I can never get up the courage to make urad or other lentils, but I will try your dal makhani this weekend. Thanks, and sal mu barak!!
A pressure cooker is a wonderful thing to have Christine, right next to the slow cooker. You’d be surprised how quick it cooks some of the tougher lentils, beans and not to mention meat!
November 15th, 2007 10:34
i’m a recent addict to dal makhni, but always thought it needed hours and hours of cooking and stirring….you make it so simple…and it looks perfect…cant wait to try it out….
I always thought the same too Arundati, until my Mom came out with this version for me. I’m sure you’ll love it!
November 15th, 2007 13:25
Hi Meena.. Are you talking about Khyber’s dal makhani ?? Or if it is someother place let me know, I’ll have one for you!! Nice recipe there, thanks for the same. Angela
Hi Angela, YESSS!!! I am talking about Khyber! Are you from Kuwait too? I can’t wait for my next trip there, plan to load up on their food!
November 15th, 2007 14:05
Looks absolutely gorgeous. I made Dal Makhini a while back too and it was just dreammmmmy. Love your version - perfect for the mingle.
Isn’t it the most perfect winter comfort food? Can’t wait for the roundup!
November 15th, 2007 17:40
thank you for posting this! it’s my absolute favorite food!
November 15th, 2007 17:43
doesn’t makhan mean fat? i’m surprised there isn’t more butter/cream/milk in this dish…pleasantly surprised, that is! now i can enjoy it without guilt.
That’s true, Kari. Makhan actually means butter, and this dish is traditionally made with loads of butter and cream. This reacipe is much less fat version due to the minimal butter and milk used. Hope you enjoy it!
November 16th, 2007 01:17
I love dal makhani! Do you think I could make this on the stove instead of a pressure cooker?
November 16th, 2007 07:21
This looks absolutely amazing. I am going to try it this weekend.
First time on your blog - the photographs are beautiful, and food presentation is also really eye catching. I hope you get your book deal soon!
Thanks Chakli! I do hope so too!
November 16th, 2007 09:43
Sounds wonderful - do have an alternative method for those who do not have a pressure cooker?
Hi Lisa, I haven’t really tried making this without a pressure cooker, since it would take ages on the stove and you might have to keep adding water to prevent it from drying, which in turn would dilute its wonderful flavour. You could definitely make it in a slow cooker. Just do the cooking in a deep pan, and once you’re ready to add the soaked lentils, pour the contents into a slow cooker, letting it cook for 4 hours on low. Let me know how it turned out if you decide to try it.
November 16th, 2007 13:38
Looks Incredibly Delicious and Mouth Watering !!
November 16th, 2007 20:13
Yes Meena, that is a plate of perfection. I truly wish I could taste it.
You must definitely try it out Cynthia, I just know you will enjoy it!
November 17th, 2007 09:14
We went travelling to India a few year ago. Splashed out to go to Bukhara in Dehli - where as well as having the most fantsic Lamb Raan - I tried Dhal Makhini for the first time.
That was it - I was hooked.
From that point on I tried DM in every restaurant that served it. Mostly excellent. I have not maangaed to find anything like it in the UK so far. Anyone help ?
Take a look at http://www.travelblog.org/Asia/India/Udaipur/blog-35950.html where you’ll see us cooking DM in a cookery school in Udaipur. It wasn’t on the list of meals to cook - but I managed to persuade them to teach it for us. Excellent.
Steve
November 19th, 2007 18:03
I was just wondering what to make with the canned black lentils that I have. Thanks for this awesome recipe.
November 21st, 2007 13:26
Wow your version looks so perfect. Creamy & delightful.
Everybody has their own versions of daal makhani. I really like the one which does not show the daal at all, its all mashed up!!
November 23rd, 2007 01:05
What a lovely picture & recipe too!
November 24th, 2007 20:22
I dont like daal but I love daal makni..will try your recipe! You said in your intro to the recipe on how you love chicken tikka, do post your recipe if you have a favourite one. Its my favourite Indian dish!
November 26th, 2007 11:27
which is this non-descript place in kuwait??????? can you believe that i am seeing your blog after ages and it is just before dinner in kuwait city. am here for a business trip. the coincidence is too much. now if you had only mentioned the name of the restaurant, i might be tasting this famous dal makhani and making you very jealous
November 26th, 2007 15:24
Hi! I wondered if you have any recipes that use fresh fenugreek/methi that you would share. I have never ever seen it fresh in our stores and yesterday, there it was staring back at me, so I had to buy it, now to use it! Thanks!
December 7th, 2007 23:21
i totally understand about a dish we cannot really replicate elsewhere
December 31st, 2007 13:39
Hi. My teenage daughter and I would like to learn some Indian cooking (this recipe in particular). We have only ever eaten Indian food in restaurants but love it, love it, love it.. Also, we want to wow our friends, non of whom think we can pull this off.
Can you suggest an easy-to-use beginners cookbook? Any other suggestions?
Cheers,
Teresa and Tasha
January 9th, 2008 10:50
can i use red chori instead of black lentils, pls reply
January 10th, 2008 14:04
Hah, I know about mee goreng!!! I could never get it right…despite multiple attempts. I think they are not telling us the secret ingredients in those pot of red-color sauce filled with cuttlefish!!!
January 18th, 2008 04:55
thanks for the lovely recipe.
January 19th, 2008 17:45
Is There a way to make this without the pressure cooker? Can it be cooked in a crockpot all day?
January 31st, 2008 03:16
Can anyone please tell me, how this CREAMY BLACK LENTILS look like.., I wanna prepare this dish, its so rich.
February 14th, 2008 01:55
Is there another name for black lentils? what would the Indian name for them be? We also got addicted to Dal Makhni here in Kuwait…but at Mughal Mahal. Been looking for the recipe ever since…Thanks so much!
They’re called Kali Urad in Hindi Roxanne, it should be easily available at Indian grocery stores. Mmm… Mughal Mahal was favourite pit-stop for their Biryani!
April 4th, 2008 12:16
HI,
I tried this recipe and love it! I have three children 4 and under, so I don’t have a lot of time. I used canned organic lentils and canned chopped tomatoes to cut my time in half. I just tasted it and it is very yummy. I’m sure it tastes even better your way. Thanks, Heather
April 11th, 2008 22:10
this was just what i was looking for. thanks. off to give it a try.
April 14th, 2008 00:38
got it just right the second batch around. made a few variations but that’s what it’s all about.
I agree tiki-tiki, food’s best enjoyed when it’s suited to your taste. Glad it came out well!
June 3rd, 2008 09:13
Thank you for this recipe - I have been looking for a simple one for years. It is my husband’s favourite and I made it very successfully once, then lost the recipe! The only trouble is we are trying to eat less fat and salt. Have you any tips for this recipe?
June 5th, 2008 14:20
thanks Meena for such a yummy looking recipe. I’m going to make it tonight. Hubby loves Dal makhani when we eat at my MIL’s house or in resaurant, now it’s my turn.
Thanks again for the simpler version.
August 17th, 2008 21:36
Looks delicious! Do you think this could be made with pre-cooked lentils? (asks the girl with a bag of Trader Joe’s pre-cooked lentils)
I’m guessing you definitely could BS, just cook it in a normal pot instead of a pressure cooker and lower the cooking time by half. Do let me know how it went.
October 8th, 2008 23:11
This recipe is absolutely fantastic! I just started living by myself and also cooking but i am enjoying the process of learning. The best thing about this recipe is that it is flavorful and does not use heavy cream etc which some recipes suggest…. but i have a problem my kitchen and house always smell of spices when i cook indian food…..if anyone has any suggestions to prevent this it would be great!
October 29th, 2008 14:14
This is by far THE BEST dal we have ever tasted, much less made ourselves! Taste of India in Minneapolis has a black lentil dal that comes close - but this is the cats pajamas!
December 30th, 2008 12:23
This is the simplest and the tastiest daal makhani. I always wanted to make daal makhani as my husband loves it, but used to think it would be difficult. But this recipe is pretty simple and tasty.
I have made it 2 times and it has turned out really good each time. I will be making this again for my potluck dinner tomorrow.
Thank you so much for sharing it with everyone!
January 17th, 2009 12:08
I tried it once and it came out very good. thankyou so much. if i have to double the quantity, would it make sense if i double all the ingredients?
February 21st, 2009 07:27
Hi, I’m looking for this daal makhani recipe since I tasted it with naan here in Thailand. I’m a filipina engaged to my indian boyfriend and want to make daal makhani for him. Thanks for posting the recipe.
February 23rd, 2009 06:31
the Daal makhani was excellent, the ingredients blended so well , I am Pakistani there is not concept of Daal makhni but i tried this and it was excellent
May 22nd, 2009 04:55
My story is very similar to yours…have been trying and trying to recreate that perfect dal makhani till destiny (rather google ;)) led me here! This recipe finally unlocked that charmed secret.
I must say that not only do you write well, you also have the gift of making food delicious on paper!
June 23rd, 2009 12:17
This is so exciting! Daal Makhani is my favorite food! I’m moving to Kuwait in a couple of months to teach and I’m definitely going to go to the restaurant you mentioned! Thank you
October 3rd, 2009 07:08
I just made this today and it’s really delicious. I didn’t have ginger garlic paste so I just mashed up my own ginger and garlic in a mortar and pestle. The texture is also very nice; I like it better than the completely soupy dals. But I would love to try the “loaded with cream and butter” variety someday.
October 13th, 2009 00:46
I am makng this tonight for my in-laws…
Hope it turns out just as well as it looks like in your pic… Thanks for the easy recipe…!!!
November 6th, 2009 18:28
I tried this recipe in a slow cooker instead of a pressure cooker and it worked great. The only substitution that I made was 1/2 a can of black beans instead of the dry kidney beans.
Thanks for a great recipe Meenakshi!
♥ Julie
December 29th, 2009 16:13
I’m a Brazilian living in Cleveland, and I love Indian food! I’ve tasted this dish at the Cafe Tandoor and I always wanted to make it! Thank you for the recipe!
January 5th, 2010 15:57
Erin:
I worked in Kuwait in the Al-Rashed Building, 3 blocks from Al-Muthana with Khyber in between. !/2 Tikka, salad, and Dal was at least a once a week affair. Just before I returned to the U.S. the first time, they opened another near the Coast Guard Station by the Pyramid Mosque and my buddies and I from KBR ate there frequently during deployment for the Iraq 2003 invasion.
You’re so right about their Dal. I’m trying your recipe tonight but with added butter and cream. I take Lipitor (LOL)
Regards,
Mike
April 12th, 2010 08:36
Wow, it came out really nice, do we have anything else which we can prepare with same dal? any other different recipe?
April 16th, 2010 19:33
I made this tonight and it turned out to be beans in a tiny bit of sauce. I think my mistake was draining the beans after they were done cooking and then adding the sauce- should I have kept the cooking water? The whole thing was not creamy as it should have been. Do you ever mash some of the beans for added creaminess?
May 28th, 2010 17:32
I’ve always enjoyed dal makhani as a treat while eating out, but have never made it at home due to the typically high saturated fat content. This version is equally satisfying as its richer counterparts, yet healthy enough to eat on a more regular basis. Thank you for posting this outstanding recipe!
After doing some research last night, I am still unclear as to exactly what type of bean this recipe requires. I believe that dal makhani is supposed to use whole ‘urad’ beans, which I think are also called ‘black lentils’ sometimes. Apparently, there are also actual black lentils, which are not urad beans.
At any rate, I can’t find either type of bean in my area, but I did have a few cups of mung beans on hand. To me, the mung beans look like green version of urad beans, so I used them as a substitute in this recipe for dinner last night. The result was amazing! I’ll still keep looking for urad and/or black lentils when I’m traveling, but I’ll happily make this with mung beans (or maybe adzuki beans) again.
I also bought a pressure cooker for making this dish. Man, I should have done that years ago. I’ve never had luck in the past with dried beans, but the pressure cooker made them quickly and perfectly tender. To those who have asked about the necessity for a pressure cooker, I would say: If you can spare $20 for an entry-level pressure cooker - do it. I got the cheapest one I could find at the local mall, and it worked beautifully. I might need to upgrade to an 8 qt. in the future (this is a 6 qt. model), but I wasn’t ready to spend $100 on the larger in-stock model right now.
Lastly, for anyone who hasn’t worked with it before, consider using ghee instead of ‘normal’ butter. This dish has so little butter, that it’s worth a few extra cents to splurge on the heavenly, nutty flavor of ghee. You’ll notice - and appreciate - the difference.
Thanks, again, for the great recipe.
P.S. Elizabeth (post 58), I had to add water after cooking the beans because mine were too dry. Just stirring in and heating enough water (and a little more skim milk) to bring the level back up to the top of the beans made a delicious gravy, just like the photo on this page. I think the stirring, alone, mashes enough beans to make the gravy.